No , you should n’t use a toothpick .

As with most baking recipes , a heap of scientific discipline and precision is required when making cheesecake from scratch , but perhaps the trickiest part of the cognitive operation is knowing when it ’s done baking . The last matter you want — after dedicating time and campaign to your formula — is a too - soft , undercooked cheesecake that ca n’t hold a cut edge . It ’s also sorry when that beautifulNew York - style cheesecakeends up over - baked , dry , and cracked .

direct from our Test Kitchen , here are a few simple tricks to test the doneness — so there ’s no enquiry that you ’ll be slice into a perfectly - baked cheesecake every clock time .

Cheesecake Supreme

Credit:Kritsada Panichgul

If you ’re using the weewee bathing tub method acting , give your cheesecake an hour of standing time ( turn the oven off and grant the cake to ride there ) to allow it to set .

3 Ways to Tell When Your Cheesecake Is Done

While the toothpick trial run has been touted as a catch - all run for cheesecake doneness , it has its drawback . Using aknifeor toothpick to prove a cheesecake may produce a snap in the top . This method acting also does n’t give an accurate psychometric test for cheesecakes made with a peck of glum pick , as you would n’t get a unclouded result at the tip of your knife .

These are our Test Kitchen ’s favourite technique for telling if cheesecake is done , along with a few more lead .

Kritsada Panichgul

Cake doneness test with finger

Credit: Scott Little

1. Give it a Jiggle

The secret to screen a cheesecake for doneness is to joggle it . set jiggle ? Gently shake off your cheesecake ( wearingoven mitts , of course of study ) . If the cheesecake looks nearly dress and only a humble dress circle in the center jiggles slimly , it ’s done . You might worry a fluid middle intend raw cheesecake , but it ’s normal and safe to consume . The center will tauten up as it cool on a cool off rack , resulting in the smooth surface you need .

cheesecake made with sour cream should joggle a small more and will have a larger soft spot in the center than other cheesecake .

2. A Gentle Touch

you may tell if a cheesecake is broil by using your hands . Use clean hands to lightly — emphasis on gentle — touch the top of the cheesecake in the center . If the surface is firm but has a slight give , it ’s done .

3. Test the Temperature

This is probably what we ’d call a last - haunt method because it makes a hole in your gorgeous cheesecake , but if you ’re concerned about nutrient safety , you may poke it with a kitchen thermometer to ensure it ’s reached the internal temperature of 150ºF. This technique works well if you project on top the cheesecake , which would hide the small jam .

To make a clear slice of cheesecake ( or any cake ) , dip your knife in hot water , wipe it dry , and piece . Repeat between cut as demand .

Practice makes staring , and you have plenty of delicious cheesecake formula to try out out and work your baking magic at home . Add some festive smell to your cheesecake , such aspumpkin spiceormaple pecan , or give the umber lover in your spirit a copious slice ofchocolate - Irish ointment cheesecake . If you ’re not up for baking , there are alsono - bake cheesecakerecipes that are just as creamy and decadent .

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake with Sugared Pepitas

Credit: Scott Little